Bagel Sandwich Menu

Along with our delicious drinks that we provide, Calamity Jane Winery & Mercantile is now offering bagel sandwiches for breakfast and lunch. We get our bagels made fresh from Black Hills Bagels in Rapid City! Bringing another dining option to Custer, South Dakota. Stop in and check us out!

Breakfast Sandwiches

Western - Ham, Cheddar Pepper Cream Cheese, Pepper-jack Cheese, Green Pepper & Choice of Bagel

Hogs & Chicks - Bacon, Egg, Onion, Chive Cream Cheese, American Cheese & Choice of Bagel

Sassy Cowgirl - Sausage, Egg, Veggie Cream Cheese, Provolone Cheese, Tomato & Choice of Bagel

Urban Cowboy - Beef, Egg, Honey Almond Cream Cheese, Pepper-jack Cheese, Green Pepper, Sprouts & Choice of Bagel

Canadian Hog - Canadian Bacon, Egg, Provolone Cheese, Sundried Tomato Basil Cream Cheese & Choice of Bagel

Build Your Own - Choice of Bagel, Choice of Cream Cheese, Choice of Meat, Choice of Cheese & Veggies

Bagel with Cream Cheese

Lunch Sandwiches

Calamity Jane - Ham, Honey Almond Cream Cheese, Swiss Cheese, Green Pepper, Tomato & Choice of Bagel

Wild Bill - Turkey, Raspberry Cream Cheese, Provolone Cheese, Sprouts, Tomato & Choice of Bagel

Rough Rider - Beef, Cheddar Pepper Cream Cheese, Green Pepper, Swiss Cheese & Choice of Bagel

Chicken Salad - Chicken Salad Mix, Lettuce, Cucumber, & Choice of Bagel

BLT - Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion Chive Cream Cheese & Choice of Bagel

Pizza Bagel - Pepperoni or Canadian Bacon, Sundried Tomato Basil Cream Cheese, Provolone Cheese & Choice of Bagel

Veg-Out - Your choice of Cream Cheese Piled High with Your Choice of Veggies & Choice of Bagel

Bagel with Cream Cheese


Blueberry, Cinnamon Raisin, Cinnamon Swirl, Cheddar, Everything, Honey Whole Wheat, Onion, & Sour Dough

Cream Cheese

Brown Sugar, Cheddar Pepper, Honey Almond, Onion Chive, Plain, Raspberry, Strawberry, Sundried Tomato, & Veggie

Extra Cream Cheese $.59


Lettuce, Tomato, Green Pepper, Sprouts, Cucumber, Onion, & Jalapenos


Pepper-Jack, Swiss, Provolone, & American


Turkey, Ham, Beef, Bacon, Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Chicken Salad, & Egg